Being accused does not mean you're guilty.
"As a criminal defense attorney in Durham, I've seen firsthand how these charges can upend lives, even when based on misunderstandings or false allegations."
- Cole Williams, Durham Criminal Defense Lawyer
In Durham County, law enforcement and prosecutors take domestic violence seriously, as reflected in recent crime statistics.
While this commitment to public safety is commendable, it can sometimes lead to overzealous prosecution or misinterpretation of complex family dynamics.
According to recent data, aggravated assaults, including those classified as domestic, have seen fluctuations across Durham's police districts, highlighting the volatile nature of these situations.
This guide aims to provide you with essential information about domestic violence charges in Durham, common legal misconceptions, the court process you might face, the potential consequences of a conviction, and strategies for building a defense tailored to the unique aspects of your legal matter.
What is Communicating Threats?
Whether you're facing charges or just want to understand your rights, knowing how to navigate the legal system in Durham County is an important aspect of protecting your future.
Remember, every case is unique, and the information provided here is not a substitute for personalized legal advice.
If you're dealing with domestic violence accusations in Durham, it's a good idea to consult with an experienced criminal defense attorney who can evaluate the specifics of your situation and help you make informed decisions about your defense strategy.
Durham defense lawyer Cole Williams is available for consultation. Call now: 919-688-2647
Understanding Domestic Violence Charges in Durham, NCDomestic violence encompasses a range of offenses that occur between people in certain types of relationships.
These relationships include current or former spouses, people who live together or have lived together, those in dating relationships, and individuals who have a child in common.
The charges can vary from misdemeanors to felonies, depending on the severity of the alleged act and injuries sustained.
Common domestic violence charges in Durham include assault on a female, communicating threats, and violation of a protective order.
More serious charges may involve assault with a deadly weapon or assault by strangulation.
It's worth noting that in Durham County, these charges are taken very seriously by law enforcement and prosecutors.
Recent statistics from the Durham Police Department show fluctuations in domestic violence incidents across different districts in Durham County.
For instance, in one recent week, District 1 reported no domestic aggravated assaults, while District 2 had one such incident. These numbers can vary significantly from week to week, illustrating the complex and often unpredictable nature of domestic situations.
One key aspect of domestic violence charges in Durham is the mandatory arrest policy.
If law enforcement responds to a domestic disturbance and finds probable cause that an act of domestic violence occurred, they are required to make an arrest.
This policy, while intended to protect victims, can sometimes lead to arrests in situations where both parties share responsibility or where the facts are unclear.
It's also important to understand that in North Carolina, including Durham, domestic violence charges are often accompanied by protective orders, such as a “50B” or “DVPO” - Domestic Violence Protective Order.
Tactics for Responding to a DVPO
Domestic Violence Protective Orders can have immediate and significant impacts on your life, potentially forcing you out of your home and restricting contact with family members.
Given the complexity of these cases and the potential for severe consequences, it makes sense to seek experienced legal representation if you're facing domestic violence charges in Durham.
An attorney familiar with local court procedures and prosecution protocols can help navigate the intricacies of your case and advocate for your best interests.
Common Misconceptions About Self-Defense in Domestic SituationsDefendants facing domestic violence charges often have certain misconceptions about self-defense that can complicate their legal situation.
One prevalent misunderstanding is the belief that claiming self-defense automatically protects you from prosecution. However, the legal reality is more nuanced.
What You Need to Know About Self Defense
In North Carolina, self-defense is an affirmative defense.
Defendants invoking this defense must prove their actions were necessary to protect themselves from imminent harm.
It's insufficient to merely claim self-defense; defendants must demonstrate they had a reasonable belief that force was necessary to prevent injury or death.
Furthermore, the nature and extent of the force used in self-defense must also be reasonable and not excessive.
Another misconception among those charged is that self-defense justifies any level of force used.
North Carolina law requires that the force used in self-defense be proportional to the threat faced. Even if initially acting in self-defense, using excessive force can still result in criminal charges.
Defendants often believe that if they didn't initiate the physical altercation, they're immune from charges.
Why You Should Hire a Lawyer for DV Charges in Durham
However, in mutual combat situations, both parties may face prosecution for an affray.
Durham Police Department statistics indicate domestic aggravated assaults occur across all districts, underscoring the fact that DV incidents occur across various social, economic, and cultural groups.
"Those accused of DV charges frequently assume that if the alleged victim doesn't want to press charges, the case will be dropped. That’s not always the case."
- Cole Williams, Criminal Defense Lawyer in Durham NC
In North Carolina, prosecutors, not alleged victims, decide whether to pursue charges.
This policy, while aimed at protecting victims from coercion, can result in cases proceeding contrary to both parties' wishes.
Defendants ALSO sometimes think a lack of visible injuries precludes domestic violence charges and prosecution for DV in court.
However, prosecutors recognize that domestic violence encompasses various forms, including threats and emotional abuse, which may not leave physical marks.
For anyone facing domestic violence accusations, understanding these legal realities is important. DV cases are often complex and deserve a thorough examination of all circumstances surrounding the incident by an experienced criminal lawyer.
The Legal Process: From Arrest to Trial in Durham CountyUnderstanding the legal process is helpful for anyone facing domestic violence charges in Durham County. The journey from arrest to trial may have several key stages, each with its own challenges and opportunities for defense.
The process typically begins with an arrest.
Should You Talk to the Police?
In Durham, as in other parts of North Carolina, law enforcement often makes arrests based on probable cause in domestic violence situations.
Following arrest, the accused is usually taken to the Durham County Detention Facility for booking and initial processing.
Next comes the first appearance, which usually occurs soon after arrest.
During this hearing, a judge informs the defendant of the charges and may set conditions of release and/or bail. In domestic violence cases, the judge may also issue a protective order, as part of the conditions of release, which can significantly impact the defendant's living situation and contact with family members.
FAQs - Assault Charges in Durham
Requiring the accused to “not contact the prosecuting witness” or “not assault, threaten, or harass the victim” as a condition of release from jail is separate, apart, and in addition to a civil domestic violence protective order pursuant to N.C.G.S. Chapter 50B.
If the charges are misdemeanors, the case may proceed directly to District Court.
For felony charges, there may be an additional step of a probable cause hearing or dismissal to the Durham County Grandy Jury and indictment process, where the prosecution must show there's enough evidence to proceed with the case.
Bond and Conditions of Release in NC
Discovery can be a critical phase in which the defense attorney reviews the evidence against their client. This may include police reports, witness statements, and any physical evidence collected.
It’s important to understand discovery is not required for criminal charges in North Carolina with original jurisdiction in District Court.
The District Attorney's office in Durham County, as is the case throughout North Carolina, is required to provide discovery to the defense in felony charges and those subject to Superior Court exclusive jurisdiction.
As may be appropriate given the unique aspects of any fact pattern, defense attorneys may challenge evidence, seek to suppress statements, and negotiate with prosecutors for reduced charges or alternative resolutions.
Complaint for Domestic Violence Protective Order
Many cases in Durham County are resolved through plea agreements.
If the case goes to trial, it will be heard either in District Court for misdemeanors or Superior Court for felonies. For misdemeanor charges, there is also a right to a de novo appeal from District Court to a Superior Court Jury Trial.
The trial process often involves jury selection (in Superior Court), opening statements, presentation of evidence, witness testimony, closing arguments, and jury deliberation.
Defendants have constitutional rights and statutory rights, including the right to remain silent, the right to confront witnesses, and the right to legal counsel.
It's worth noting that the timeframe for this process can vary significantly.
While some cases may be resolved relatively quickly, others can take months or even years to conclude, especially if they go to trial.
Data from the Durham Police Department shows fluctuations in violent crime rates across districts, which can impact court schedules and case processing times.
What Happens if You Violate a 50B Order?
For anyone navigating this complex legal landscape in Durham County, a clear understanding of each stage of the process is helpful for making informed decisions about defense strategy.
Each case, like each person accused of domestic violence charges in Durham, is unique. As such, it’s a good idea to consult with an experienced criminal lawyer.
Frequently Asked Questions About Domestic Violence Charges in DurhamPeople facing charges often wonder if the alleged victim can simply "drop" the charges. In Durham, as in the rest of North Carolina, the decision to pursue or drop charges ultimately lies with the prosecutor, not the alleged victim. Even if the alleged victim doesn't want to proceed, the prosecutor may choose to continue with the case if they believe there's enough evidence. However, the alleged victim's cooperation (or lack thereof) can significantly influence the prosecutor's decision and the strength of the case.
A protective order, also known as a restraining order or DVPO or 50B in North Carolina, can significantly impact your daily life. It may require you to leave your home, prohibit contact with the alleged victim and possibly your children, and restrict you from certain locations. Violating a protective order is a separate criminal offense. Domestic Violence Protective Orders can affect your right to possess firearms and may impact employment, especially if your job requires a security clearance. It's extremely important to understand and strictly adhere to the terms of any DV protective order issued against you.
If you're falsely accused of domestic violence in Durham, it's important to take the situation seriously. First, do not violate any protective orders, even if you believe the accusations are false. Avoid any contact with the accuser. Document everything you can remember about the incident in question that might support your side of the story. This could include text messages, emails, or witness accounts. Avoid discussing the case with anyone other than your attorney. Durham Police Department crime statistics show that domestic violence accusations occur across all districts, indicating how common these situations are and the importance of a proper legal response.
Yes, there may be alternatives to trial for some domestic violence cases in Durham. Deferred prosecution and/or a 15A Conditional Discharge may allow the defendant to complete certain requirements (such as counseling or community service) in exchange for having charges dismissed upon successful completion. Another possibility is plea bargaining, where the defendant pleads guilty to a lesser charge. However, eligibility for these programs depends on various factors, including the specific charges, the defendant's criminal history, and the prosecutor's willingness to offer alternatives. Each case is different. Seek legal counsel.